Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Your Biggest Competition-You

An editor friend, who runs regular competitions at their website, recently received a request from a writer to run a competition soley for unpublished authors.  The writer’s reasoning was that it took great effort to write a good story and they didn’t stand a chance against ‘established authors’.  Of course, the editor politely declined.

It got me thinking that that writer may not realise two important things.  As writers,

1.      We compete with every other writer out there, established or not.
2.      You are only really competing against yourself.

Now these two statements may seem completely oppositional.  How you feel about the quality of your writing and the rejection of your writing is probably one of the biggest hurdles a new writer needs to overcome.

A REAL STRUGGLE

I am wading through the editing of a book I wrote last year—I know it’s a long time but I kept getting caught up with short stories; then there’s the kid’s stuff.   Three chapters I edited recently were a real struggle.  I vaguely remember that, around the time I wrote them, I threw a hissy fit, cried myself to sleep for three days and informed my husband I was the lousiest writer on the planet.  The writing was so bad in my mind, I couldn’t go back to the novel for a week due to the fear I may accidentally read the pages and want to give up permanently.

Some twelve months later, when I came to edit these offending pages, I realise, I was right originally.  They were bad. As I was reading them, I thought: Gawd, who wrote this rubbish?  But I’ve grown since then, so instead of a tantrum, I told myself: Thank goodness I’ve improved. 

Even when I finished the edit on them, my best first reader, Hubby, shook his head and said, ‘They need more work.’  He then added, ‘See you always accuse me of bias when I tell you something is good.  Now this isn’t so good and I’m telling you.’  I tried to be pleased at his honesty but it did smart a little, even though he was right.  I knew it was poor writing, he said it was poor writing; therefore, it probably was poor writing by anyone’s standards.

BAD WRITER?

Does that make me a bad writer with no chance?  No.
 
Since I wrote those passages, my stories have won multiple short story competitions and a few are now published.  That pathetic writing was just a slimy stepping stone to the better writing.  There will be hundreds, if not thousands, of these stones. Sometimes, as you put your foot down on one slippery little monster, you instinctively know that this is not going to be good.  But if it’s the only way across the stream, then step on it you must.

Am I racing the writer guy next to me with the dainty little light step, who seems to skim across the stones, reaching the amazing-winning awards-writing bank before me?  No, his stones are different and his journey is different.  Quite possibly he started before me.  So what if he entered the same writing competition as me and won?  Maybe it’s my turn next time.  And at least I have the story I wrote and the experience.  That's money in the bank right there.


BALANCE OF POWER

The only thing in my power, with regards to writing, is me.  I can’t make an editor or a judge like my work if it’s not their cup of tea or if the quality of my work hasn’t reached their standards yet. My job is to just keep going, practicing and honing and learning everything I can about me and the craft.

In a writing competition the Writer Me of a year ago wouldn’t stand a chance against the Writer Me who writes this blog today. Tens of thousands of words now separate us.  And those words have made a difference.  This me, has to edit what that poor chump wrote a year ago, so I should know.  And don’t feel sorry for them and their lack of talent either.  Feel sorry for me, I have to fix up the mess.  It is very hard work.  

Next year, I hope to look back on this year’s effort with slight disdain.  That is my goal.  If I’ve worked hard enough, I should be better at the craft.  In fact, I spend every day separating myself from the Writer Me of the day before with a few more thousand words of experience.  I hope next year, also, to be encouraged by my improvement and grateful to the Writer Me who spent another year working at her apprenticeship by belting out pages and pages of good and bad writing.

In the end, it is a wise writer who remembers, that just like our heroes, you can’t always win but as long as you are in the game—and the longer you are in the game—there is always a chance.

14 comments:

  1. A wonderful summary, Sue. The stepping stone analogy is particularly apt. Watch the slippery ones!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you David. I do hope I don't send any of the slippery ones to your competitions.

    And I would like to take this opportunity to publicly thank you for running Stringybark Competitions (folks you can find the link to David's wonderful site on the left hand side of this page).

    I have enjoyed entering them-and losing and winning. But, of course, each one was a winner for me, as I got to keep the story.

    Thank you for your kind comments.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So insightful, this. I relate hugely to the part where you found out you were right about the bad pages. After decades of writing I've learned to pay attention to that. The good pages flow easily. But if I start to feel a dragging - as if the parking brake was left on - I know there's a problem for real and I'm headed in the wrong direction. If I ignore that feeling and proceed, I only have more rewriting to do later! Thanks, Sue.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you Sarah for your wonderful comment. It means a lot coming from you with your amazing career.

    Yes, it has been an emotional roller coaster since I restarted writing in earnest. Learning to understand, why you feel a certain way when you write was an important lesson. Instinct is everything. And those offending chapters are totally scrapped-wrong plot direction but right lesson.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Susan

    Last night I listened to an All In the Mind podcast on achieving excellence in sport and music, and the experts were saying how doing something to the edge of your ability creates the most favourable conditions for learning.

    They repeated the view that it takes 10,000 hours to become and expert, and explained how this is because we need that kind of dedicated, determined focus to create a "broadband" of neuronal pathways in our brain that make it easier and easier to perform well.

    I was just thinking how that also applied to writing when I saw your blog post - it fits in well with what you and Sarah suggest here.

    Good luck with your writing, congratulations on your story success and your thoughtful post. I found the link to Stringbark short story comp and tweeted it, too, thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you Elizabeth for your comment and such kind words. We authors live for the kind words, don't we?

    I began this blog because I really don't understand the writing process. I do it and I seem to be getting better but I am not truly sure why it gets easier. As I write each post I seem to learn a little bit more about how it works.

    It just seems you make these leaps in ability and word output.
    I like the idea of neuron pathways being built. Gawd knows, I need some at my age.

    Stephen King wrote in "Danse Macabre" that if you write every day you will build big writing muscles. Then you write yourself to a place where your talent will meet luck. And I believe that is all we can hope to do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm certainly familiar with looking back over something I've written and realizing it sucks. I spent a year and half on a book--writing it, editing it. I then started another book and worked on it for six months. Then went back to the first one and realized the entire story needed trashed. I'd grown so much as a writer in the two years since I started the first story that, if I wanted to tell that story properly, I'd need to start over from scratch. So that's where I'm at right now with my new work in progress.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks Abbie for your comment. It can be frustrating but in the end you want to put out the best work you can.

    I have a 420 page MS that I stopped after 6 mths of work and I am not game to look at it. But it's where I learnt so much and that is good enough.

    I think you learn more from writing a book than you could learn in a course.

    I've heard most successful novelists have a first book hidden away somewhere never to see the light of day. So, I guess we are on the right track. :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Doris,

    Thank you for your lovely compliment. I really appreciate anyone taking the time to read my ideas. I hope other writers new and old find something in them.

    I visited your blog. Love the muddy boots and pics. You are a fun gal. :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Interestingly enough i was watching a completely rubbish movie last night and beloved and i engaged in the 'why was it so awful' chat about script and acting and the fine line between a great film and a terrible film and wondering how some things got made and did the producers, etc know it was a stinker? And so i turned to my own writing (currently in final re-write/edit of novel for PhD) and wondered if i could tell the difference anymore? Sometimes I think I'm just magic there on the page, sometimes I know I'm rubbish. What we need is the eyes and truth of others and our own belief to keep going. You're completely right - our main competition is ourself.

    Enjoyed your blog, have a squizz at mine - http://jactherat.wordpress.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Thanks 4 visiting the blog and reading my post. I've just written a blog post, dealing with that to a degree http://susanmaywordadventures.blogspot.com.au/2012/04/whos-afraid-of-little-blank-page.html

      I think we must persist with our work because we can't live without it. Good or bad, I am happy to churn out stories because it fills me with a wonder and experiences I can't have in the real world.

      Thank you for your kind compliments on my blog. I visited your blog and I love your post about things you (I) love. I also love your hair colour and your children. You look like my kind of people.

      I really appreciate you stopping by. Thank you.

      Delete
  11. This is so, so true. I'm my own biggest critic. Usually when I'm writing something, I'll tell myself it sucks. Sometimes it isn't as bad as I thought when I go back and edit... but sometimes it is, and I know how to fix it.

    I started this writers' questionnaire by Kelcey Parker and plan on returning to it soon. Maybe it'll help you out, too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Liz, thank you for stopping by and leaving a comment. I dropped by your blog and left a comment too. Lovely blog by the way.

      I know how you feel about being over critical. If you read my latest post its aimed square at this problem. http://susanmaywordadventures.blogspot.com.au/2012/04/whos-afraid-of-little-blank-page.html

      You may identify with it. Thank you for taking the time to drop by. I so appreciate it.

      Delete